Standing in the pet food aisle can feel like reading a foreign language. Bags promise premium, natural and holistic nutrition, and the photos look appetizing. The most useful information, though, is usually in the smaller print. In the United States, pet food labeling is shaped by federal rules and by model regulations developed by the Association of American Feed Control Officials, known as AAFCO, which many states adopt. Here is how to make sense of the main parts.
The product name tells you more than you think
Under AAFCO’s model rules, the wording of a product name signals how much of a named ingredient is in the food. As a general guide:
- “Beef Dog Food” or “Salmon Cat Food”: the named ingredient makes up most of the product, at least 95 percent not counting added water.
- “Beef Dinner,” “Chicken Entree” or “Salmon Formula”: the named ingredient makes up at least 25 percent, not counting water. Other ingredients may make up the majority.
- “With Chicken”: the named ingredient needs to be only 3 percent of the product.
- “Chicken Flavor”: there must be enough to be detected, but no specific percentage is required.
So “Chicken Cat Food” and “Cat Food With Chicken” can be very different products.
The ingredient list
Ingredients are listed in descending order by weight, including their water content, before processing. That means ingredients with high water content, like fresh meat, can appear near the top even if they contribute less to the final dry product than ingredients further down. The ingredient list is helpful for identifying things your pet should avoid, such as a known allergen, but it does not tell you on its own whether a food is high quality or complete.
Guaranteed analysis
This panel lists minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat, and maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture. Some foods list more. These figures are on an as-fed basis, so comparing a canned food, which contains a lot of water, to a dry kibble directly can be misleading. Your veterinarian can help you compare foods on a more equal footing if you need to.
The nutritional adequacy statement
This may be the single most important line on the label. It tells you whether the food is intended to be complete and balanced, and for which life stage, such as growth, adult maintenance or all life stages. It also tells you how that was determined: either the food was formulated to meet established nutrient profiles, or it went through feeding trials.
If a product is labeled for intermittent or supplemental feeding only, it is not meant to be a pet’s main diet. Treats and some toppers fall into this category. Puppies and kittens need food appropriate for growth, and large-breed puppies may have specific needs, so check that the statement matches your pet.
What labels do not tell you
Words like “premium,” “gourmet” and “holistic” generally have no official definition. “Natural” has a defined meaning in AAFCO guidance, but it does not mean a food is better for your pet. Feeding directions are starting points, not rules. The label cannot tell you whether a food suits your individual pet’s health, so bring the bag or a photo to your veterinarian and ask. For more background, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has consumer information on pet food at fda.gov.
Comparing Foods on a Dry Matter Basis
The guaranteed analysis can be misleading when you compare foods with very different moisture levels. Converting to a dry matter basis removes the water from the picture so you can compare more fairly. The math is simple.
- Find the moisture percentage on the guaranteed analysis.
- Subtract it from 100 to get the dry matter percentage.
- Divide the nutrient percentage by the dry matter percentage, then multiply by 100.
A worked example
Imagine a canned food lists 8 percent crude protein and 78 percent moisture. Its dry matter is 100 minus 78, or 22 percent. Divide 8 by 22 and multiply by 100, and you get roughly 36 percent protein on a dry matter basis.
Now imagine a dry kibble lists 26 percent protein and 10 percent moisture. Its dry matter is 90 percent. Divide 26 by 90 and multiply by 100, and you get roughly 29 percent protein on a dry matter basis.
At first glance the kibble seemed to have more than three times the protein of the canned food. On a dry matter basis, the canned food actually has more. This kind of comparison is useful, but it is still only one piece of the picture. Protein quality, digestibility and your pet’s individual needs matter too.
Calories and Feeding Amounts
Many labels include a calorie statement, often shown as kilocalories per kilogram and per cup or can. This is one of the most practical numbers on the bag, because two foods that look similar can differ in calories per cup. When switching foods, compare calorie content so you do not accidentally overfeed or underfeed.
The feeding guide on the bag is a starting point based on weight. Activity, age, spay or neuter status, health and environment all change how much a pet needs. Weigh your pet periodically and ask your veterinarian for a target body condition and a daily calorie estimate. Remember to account for treats, which can add up quickly.
A Label-Reading Checklist
- Does the nutritional adequacy statement say complete and balanced for my pet’s life stage?
- Is it labeled for all life stages, and if so, is that appropriate for my pet? Some all-life-stages foods are formulated to meet growth needs, which may be more than an adult or senior needs.
- For large-breed puppies, does the label address growth for large-size dogs?
- What is the calorie content per cup or can?
- Are there ingredients my vet has told me to avoid?
- Does the manufacturer provide contact information so I can ask questions?
Common Label Misunderstandings
- “The first ingredient is meat, so it must be high protein.” Because ingredients are listed by weight before processing, water-rich meats can rank first without dominating the final product.
- “Grain-free means healthier.” Grain-free is not automatically better. If you are considering grain-free or other specialized diets, ask your veterinarian about the current understanding and whether it suits your pet.
- “By-products are low quality.” The term covers a range of ingredients, some of which are nutritious. The label term alone does not tell you about quality.
- “More expensive means better.” Price reflects many factors, including marketing. Ask your vet to help you weigh options.
Questions to Ask a Pet Food Company
Some veterinary nutrition organizations suggest contacting manufacturers with questions such as these:
- Do you employ a qualified nutrition professional, such as a board-certified veterinary nutritionist or someone with an advanced degree in animal nutrition?
- Who formulates your foods, and what are their credentials?
- What quality-control measures do you use?
- Can you provide the calorie content and full nutrient analysis for a specific product?
A company that answers clearly and promptly is usually a good sign. This article is general information; your veterinarian can help you choose a food for your pet.